Contents
At a glanceSide-by-side comparisonBrightness and reliabilityFitting and costWhere each one works bestLifespan and upkeepOur verdictFAQsYou want light outside, but the nearest socket is in the kitchen and you are not keen on digging up the lawn for cables. Solar lights look like the easy answer. The question is whether they will be bright enough, and whether they will still work in a British January. For some spots they are perfect. For others, mains is better.
Solar lights charge from daylight and switch on at dusk. Mains lights run from your home's electricity, either wired in or plugged into an outdoor socket. Each suits different jobs. This guide compares them on brightness, reliability, fitting and cost so you can choose the right one for each part of your garden. We also cover cost and how long each type tends to last.
At a glance
Side-by-side comparison
| Feature | Solar lights | Mains outdoor lights |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Borders, paths, fences and spots far from power | Front doors, drives, patios and steps |
| Brightness | Low to moderate | Moderate to very bright |
| Winter performance | Reduced run time and brightness | Same all year |
| Fitting | Push in or screw up, no wiring | Needs wiring or an outdoor socket |
| Electrician needed | No | Usually, for wired fittings |
| Running cost | Nothing | Small, especially with LED |
| Lifespan | Battery often needs replacing | Long, with fewer parts to fail |
| Control | Automatic dusk sensor | Switches, timers, sensors or smart control |
Brightness and reliability
Mains lights win clearly here. They give the same output every night, all year, and they can be very bright. Solar lights depend on how much daylight they caught that day. In June, a good solar light can run all evening. In December, it may glow faintly for a couple of hours. If you need to see the step to your front door every night, mains is the safer choice.
Fitting and cost
Solar lights are cheap and easy to fit. You push stakes into the soil or screw lanterns to a fence. There are no cables, no permits and no electrician. Mains lights cost more to install, because outdoor wiring should be done by a qualified electrician and may need certifying. Once fitted, mains LED lights cost very little to run, and solar lights cost nothing. Over a few years, the difference in running cost is small either way.
Where each one works best
Solar is ideal for marker lights along a path, uplights in borders, lanterns on a fence and anything far from the house. Mains is better for security lights, front door lights, step lights and patio lighting you rely on. Many gardens use both: mains near the house where it matters most, solar further out where it is a nice extra. That way you get light you can rely on near the door and an easy, cheap glow further out.
Lifespan and upkeep
Mains outdoor lights have fewer parts to fail and often last many years. Solar lights have batteries that wear out, often after a couple of seasons, and panels that need wiping. Cheaper solar lights can crack or rust. Choosing solar lights with replaceable batteries, and taking budget ones in over winter, helps them last longer. Mains fittings need little more than an occasional clean. Check the battery size before you buy.
Our verdict
Choose solar for decoration and gentle guidance: borders, paths, fences and spots where running power would be a pain. Accept that winter performance will be weaker.
Choose mains for anything you depend on: the front door, drive, steps and a patio you use often. It costs more to install but works every night. For most gardens, a mix of the two gives the best balance of cost and reliability.
Shop the range
Frequently asked questions
Do solar lights work on cloudy days?
They still charge from daylight on cloudy days, but more slowly. After a dull day they will run for less time and may be dimmer. A few dull days in a row can leave them barely lit. Larger panels and batteries cope better.
Do I need an electrician for outdoor mains lighting?
For hard-wired outdoor lights, yes, in most cases. Outdoor electrical work in England and Wales often needs to meet Part P rules. Plug-in outdoor lights used with a weatherproof outdoor socket are simpler, but the socket itself should be fitted by an electrician.
Are mains outdoor lights expensive to run?
No. Modern LED outdoor lights use very little power. A wall light used for a few hours a night costs only a small amount over a year. Adding a dusk sensor or PIR sensor keeps costs down further.
Can I mix solar and mains lights in one garden?
Yes, and many people do. Use mains lights near the house for doors and the patio, and solar lights in borders and along far paths. Try to keep the colour of the light similar, ideally warm white, so the garden looks consistent.




